AA MINORITY REPORT 2017 (revised)

Click here

Saturday 3 March 2012

AA Minority report 2012 (continued)(7)


Section Two

Business has no business in A.A.

Extract from Tradition six:

An AA group ought never endorse, finance, or lend the A.A. name to related facility or outside enterprise lest problems of money, property, and prestige divert us from our primary purpose.”

Business has no business in A.A. If A.A. members allow it on separate tables in A.A. meetings and events, then as Bill W. put it “every ad man and salesman in Alcoholics Anonymous would soon be selling A.A.’s wares, willy-nilly. We would loose control of our public relations.” (Bill W. A.A. Comes of Age page 130-131). Our ubiquitous and ever perennial “promoter friend” has been, and always will be, with us and he will always need to be restrained. Today A.A. business thrives, anything from a Big Book study guide, CD, T shirt, to a bumper sticker. (Google search: Alcoholics Anonymous merchandise for a list of companies trading off the A.A. Name). By Tradition, A.A. members need to be aware that these outside enterprises ought never be mixed in A.A. groups or A.A. events.

A few select items:

SPEAKER WATER
Sober Speaker Water from Natural Springs - 16.9floz.
Attention Meeting Secrataries!!! [sic] Let your speakers feel the gratitude with our signature SPEAKER WATER!! The most refreshing h2o available for speakers of all kinds Attention Speakers!!! We thank you for carrying The Message of experience strength and hope. Each sleek plastic bottle is 16.9floz. Guaranteed to keep you sober while you share. Our Price: $1.00

Recovery "Welcome" Newcomer Chocolate Bar
this Premium Chocolate Bar is the perfect gift for any Newcomer! This is a very unique and fun way to say Welcome! This Recovery Bar comes in either Milk Chocolate or White Chocolate. It measures approx. 6.5" x 1.5".
Our Price: $4.95

Bill W. Bobblehead
This Resin figure of the AA Founder makes a super fun gift! 7 inches tall.
Our Price: $21.95

AA Big Book Study Edition
6"x9" Leather Bound Hard Cover Retail Price: $32.00 The First 164 pages of The Big Book with lined pages opposite text for note taking

Lost and found Book Bindery
If you have a Big Book, then you already know how important they are. Most of us (including me) owe our lives to the message this book carries. We have "marked them up" in every way imaginable and every note has a special meaning in our recovery.

Big Book Study Guide
The purpose of this Study Guide is to enable the student to better understand the information the authors of the book Alcoholics Anonymous … …

Gold plated medallion
4c Gold Leaf Plated AA Annual Sobriety Birthday Medallion/Coin £15.00
Plated with 24c gold leaf, this beautiful AA sobriety medal has a raised circle/triangle showing the year of sobriety with the Legacies of; Recovery, Unity & Service. The words, “To Thine Own Self Be True”, are stamped around the coin’s edge. The Short version of the Serenity Prayer is stamped on the reverse.

A newcomer victim of Big Book Study struggles with her step workbook:

I am concerned that we are not reaching people who cannot read well or cannot read at all. I am new to the program and making my way through the Steps. I struggle to understand the "Twelve and Twelve," even with a college degree and help from my sponsor and other AAs. Meanwhile, my roommate, also newly sober and with a grade school education, can't make any sense of her Step workbook and is about to give up. How many people do we lose this way? How many, when asked to read from the Big Book at a meeting, stumble through a few sentences, acutely embarrassed, and never come back? A literature-based program effectively shuts out people who desperately need help but do not have good reading skills”. (Dear Grapevine, Shut Out; A.A. Grapevine November 2010)

Kelly Foundation Big Book Study/ step guide books, Recovery Dynamics materials, Books by Joe McQ:

Other newcomers’ views:

I've been doing telephone service since I got sober. I answer the phones at our intergroup office in the mornings. Some of my favourite calls are from newcomers who say, "I need to go to some of your classes." They think we're in school! …” (Class is in Session. A.A. Grapevine November 2010)

The view of Bill W. Co-Founder of A.A:

Education will not only pay off in numbers treated; it can pay off even more handsomely in prevention… … Now who is going to do all this education? Obviously, it is both a community job and a job for specialists. Individually, we AAs can help, but AA as such cannot, and should not, get directly into this field.” (Bill W. AA Grapevine March 1958. Language of the Heart page 186-187)

The view of Norman Y in 1977, who Joined A.A. in 1939:

“‘I never read a word in A.A.’ he said. ‘You don’t have to read. You don’t have to have all these pamphlets they put out. You can learn to live this program by learning to think. A.A. is a wonderful thing to know and apply’ he said, ‘- but in your life. You’ve got to live it out in the street. You see somebody having a little problem, help them, no matter who they are. That’s A.A.” –Norman Y. (Dr. Bob and The Good Old Timers page 251-250)

When Norman finally got a job, in 1940, helping other blind people, he started to put aside ten percent of his salary to pay for speaking trips, contributions at meetings, and other A.A. expenses.” (Dr. Bob and The Good Old Timers page 182-183)

Have some quarters of the fellowship lost sight of the A.A. spirit of gratitude and service, freely given without need to satisfy their cravings for personal prestige or material reward?

This trend in A.A. merchandise began perhaps, many years ago with our “promoter friend” in the plastics moulding industry selling bits of plastic to the A.A. group; a reward to man, for what is but God’s grace; The chip to wedge open the door to a free market. “To Thine Own ‘Self’ be True” instead of “But for the grace of God go ‘I’ ” An appeal to the senses and a round of applause to inflate an ego. Afterward this can be viewed as an A.A. group that “wallowed in emotionalism and had mistaken it for true religious feeling” (Step 2 Twelve Steps and Twelve Traditions page 33). “This had been our blind spot. We had supposed we had humility when we really hadn’t.” (Step Two, Twelve Steps and Twelve Traditions page 33). If reward is to be given at all, better a gift of A.A. literature to encourage a newcomer’s deeper understanding of his illness and to broaden his understanding of honesty and humility.

A victim of A.A business shares her story:

Extract from “unrecorded”, A.A. Grapevine August 2007 Vol. 64 No. 3

..Some speakers are recorded without their knowledge or permission. For instance, one friend of mine, a gay schoolteacher, was horrified to discover that his AA talk had been recorded and sold without his knowledge. Since part of his story included a description of how his recovery from alcoholism helped him accept his sexual orientation, he was concerned that his professional standing would be jeopardized if the recording wound up in the wrong hands. Of course, the whole situation could have been avoided if the taper simply had asked his permission to record the talk.

Another AA member I know, a clergyman, delivered a rather earthy talk at an AA convention. Someone sent the recording to his bishop, landing the clergyman in hot water. Certainly, the tattletale was a large part of the problem here. But if there's one place where we shouldn't have to worry about the repercussions of our sharing, it's an AA meeting. So, what does "anonymous" mean to members during these times of ever-present audio recorders?

.One time, I walked into an AA convention where I was speaking and was surprised to see the taper set up with dozens of pre-made labels with my full name emblazoned on them. I told him to blot out my last name. He begrudgingly complied. No one on the committee had mentioned that they intended to record and sell my talk… … Another time, I was seated on the dais as a banquet speaker during another AA convention. The tapers bustled about, setting up their recording system. Finally, I said, "Is anyone going to ask me if it's all right to record my talk?" They were perplexed by the question…………… Similarly, if we have to agree to be recorded before being invited to tell our AA stories, then Alcoholics Anonymous has lost its way………. Evidently, many audio recording businesses aren't familiar with the last page of the "A.A. Guidelines on Conferences…….Some tapers act as "booking agents" for AA meetings, conventions, round-ups, and conferences. They're business people, and they recommend, as speakers, those whose recordings sell lots of copies: the polished, the sensational, the humorous, and the well-known. Generally, tapers won't recommend speakers who won't allow their talks to be recorded, because it's a bad business decision for them…….. I'd like to see AA wean itself from its dependence on tapers……………….. I don't want to walk away from the AA meeting with a brand-new CD. I want to walk away from the AA meeting with an empty hand, a full heart, and a new twist on an old message that gives the recipient a big spiritual dividend--while no one realizes a dime in profit. Anonymous

It is a sad day for A.A., when speakers are chosen for their innate ability to captivate and entertain an audience. Have conventions become a business? Have they become a power game for “Our promoter friend” to exploit what Dr. Silkworth described as “unhealthy emotionalism”? (A.A. Comes of Age appendix E:a)

Say no to nothing, A German recluse bursts out of her shell at ICYPAA 51

I set down my bags, went out for a smoke, and was kidnapped by ICYPAA old-timers. I got back about 13 hours later with two other AAs who crashed in my bed. After two hours of sleep, I jumped out of bed and yearned for more. That was two days before the conference actually started… … I have truly been rocketed into a fourth dimension I never knew existed. I always believed I would experience the Promises in my life, but I never expected them to all be thrown at me over one short weekend. I stood in the meeting room with 3,500 drunks under the age of 30, and I had chills running down my spine and tears in my eyes. Little did I know this was the mere beginning--the pre-conference speaker. I stood on my chair and danced to Bob Marley. After all, this was why I came; however, I was feeling very uncomfortable and uncool… … … The spirituality in the room could have knocked me over. I took a second to recompose myself, then I leaned over to my new friend, with his green, red and yellow mohawk, and said, "This is it." He smiled and looked down at me and just said, "Yeah, ha-ha, awesome, right?" I knew at that moment I had found that feeling I had chased since my first drink: total acceptance, absolute love and a freedom to act stupid… … … The first bit of advice I received was very useful. I was riding through Atlanta in the back of a pickup truck, and the "old-timers," who had been to at least three ICYPAAs before, said, "Say no to nothing, do it all, and sleep as little as possible… … … But before I knew it, I was on the stage at a nightclub full of sober people, raving with the D.J. I stopped and thought, Can this be right? Can this be spiritual? Can sobriety be so much fun? I asked God for an intuitive thought or decision, only to be thrown back into reality by a song that said, "Shut up and dance… … … At the beginning of each meeting, the speaker would introduce him or herself, "Hi, I am_____ and I am an alcoholic," and then the thousands of young people would return with, "Hi, _____, we love you, _____, lots and lots and lots and WHOOOOOLE BUNCHES! Whooo!" (This was accompanied by a group pelvic thrust toward the speaker which seemed to get bigger later in the weekend)… … … That is the attitude I left with. If you think you can't enjoy life in sobriety, "B__________t!"

There was so much power, gratitude and inspiration in Atlanta that I can never imagine having the desire to drink return to me… … … We are the next generation of old-timers, the future of this Fellowship. We, young people in AA around the world, are on fire with recovery.” (Say no to nothing, A German recluse bursts out of her shell at ICYPAA 51 AA Grapevine February 2010)

THAT voice, I thought. That's the woman on the tape! ... … … The woman whose voice I recognized was sitting in front, sharing on gratitude … … I had goose bumps as I listened to her; I began to shake, and my heart pounded in my chest… … It was Sandy… … After the meeting I turned to my sponsor and my friend and said, ‘I have to talk to that woman.’… … … I touched her arm… … … she had no idea who I was. ‘I recognized your voice,’ I managed to choke out. "I have one of your tapes. You saved my life.’… … … I dragged out one of my boxes of AA speaker tapes. I probably have over 100 tapes. I was going to find Sandy's tape. I hadn't listened to it in years, but I knew it was in one of two boxes. I opened the first box and sighed. The tapes were piled on top of each other with no order to them, no neat little rows. I knew I was in for a long afternoon. I reached in and pulled out the first tape my fingers touched. I turned it over: The tape had a black and red label on it and the name Sandy was written across it with a date. (THE VOICE ON THE TAPE After almost two decades, she stumbles upon the woman who saved her life. AA Grapevine November 2010)

Extract from “A New Approach to Psychotherapy in Chronic Alcoholism,” by Psychiatrist Dr. W.D Silkworth M.D Journal Lancet, July 1939:

These ex-alcoholic men and women number about one hundred at present … … … Many creeds are represented among the group and the greatest harmony prevails. … … … Considering the presence of the religious factor, one might expect to find an unhealthy emotionalism and prejudice. This is not the case, however;” (A.A. Comes of Age, appendix E:a, pages 304-305)

A victim of unhealthy emotionalism shares her story:

At the 2005 International Convention, an old-timer began to tell his story onstage at the closing meeting… … Audience members called out, "Who are you? ... … The old-timer couldn't hear what they were shouting, and he began again. Again the audience shouted at him, "Who are you?" He became flustered and lost his train of thought. He couldn't regain it, and he was ushered off the stage. I was so sad that we missed this treasured member's story due to formality of introduction. Please, let's remember to honour our old-timers and all our members …” (Dear Grapevine, formulaic greetings; AA Grapevine July 2010)

The history of Synanon tells its own story. Synanon cult leader Chuck D. was “said to be an admired speaker at A.A. meetings”: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Synanon

The Synanon cult provided everything its members needed, from merchandise to alcohol free dances:

Every year companies donate products to the Synanon Foundation by the carload: beef, shoes, furniture, clothing and building materials. ("Our tax-exempt privilege gives us the right, really, to hustle goods and services," says Dederich. "And they can write it off.") Synanon is also the nation's second largest supplier of promotional specialities—those ballpoint pens, wallets and T-shirts given away as merchandising gimmicks.”
(Chuck Dederich Still Rules Synanon, but Now He Has 1,300 Subjects and a $22 Million Empire -- By Barbara Wilkins --PEOPLE magazine's archive: October 11, 1976, Vol. 6, No. 15:

Many men flocked to Synanon's alcohol-free dances to do the Hoopla with attractive Synanite women--after first playing The Game.” [Photo Los Angeles Times]



Comment: There's always a fast buck to be made and Alcoholics Anonymous is no exception! Now we've decided to get into the true spirit of private enterprise and so we'll be bringing out our own “Get rich quick” scheme in the near future complete with workbooks, CDs (even DVDs) etc and featuring our very own panel of Big Book experts who will available both online (via Skype) and LIVE at a meeting near you! Can't get a sponsor? No worries! Just sign up for our special deal, all inclusive sponsorship package! For a very modest fee we will provide someone to harangue you over the phone, ask you if you've done your “six suggested things” for the day, and whether you have adopted the appropriate position for your morning prayer. We can guarantee regular scolding, berating, reproofs, rebukes, reprimands and any other forms of abuse that spring to mind! In no time at all you will feel like a totally inadequate adult – we even provide an extended warranty to that effect – and at only a small additional cost! Find out how good it feels to be humiliated! No stone left unturned! Every area of your life invaded! That'll put you in your place!

Just kidding! …. Wellllll...  maybe not!

Cheerio

The Fellas (Friends of Alcoholics Anonymous)