AA MINORITY REPORT 2017 (revised)

Click here

Monday 11 June 2012

We are responsible!


We received the following communication some while ago. After careful consideration we decided to publish the article in full such is the serious nature of its content (with only one edit to preserve anonymity):


March 1, 2011

Re: Making AA Safer for all members.

We know there was a Member Safety subcommittee formed in New York General Service Office and we know that no real action of any kind was taken. So we are wondering if you on the General Service Board (GSB) and in the General Service Office GSO could ask other trustees what’s going on in their areas and do they have some of these problems.

One of the problems we experience is that there are some 3000 AA meetings in the Los Angeles Area and there are only 70 General Service Rep’s that attend any one Westside Monthly District Meeting. (This group never gave us time to discuss this issue although we repeatedly tried.)
We were thinking it would be great if AAWS AA GSO and the Board/Delegates and all our groups could participate and act in unity with us to help make AA safe. AA is no longer safe.

So, the fact that AA has had predators in it’s fellowship since it’s beginning, is its skeleton in the closet, that we feel needs to be addressed.

A good case in point, two women who were raped in Covina, California by an AA member that they met in an AA meeting. Clearly this is an AA issue that must be addressed by AA as both victim and predator met in an AA meeting.

Following is the rest of the story; These two women were told by the fellowship that they should trust the fellowship, “that their best thinking had got them to Alcoholics Anonymous.” They were also told that until they could find a God of their own understanding that they should “Make the group their higher power”. These are not uncommon terms used in the room. And based on these beliefs, when the men offered them rides etc. they accepted on the basis that they could trust these individuals.
What is wrong with this picture?

As fellow sober members, we’re sure we can all agree that we want to stop the victimization of newcomers in any form.
A group of concerned long time and new AA members decided this is very important. So important, we have written literature and made a pamphlet. We feel it is imperative that we act swiftly in regards to this internal problem. Too many have already left AA never to return. Too many will die. Many will drink again. Years of this behavior can’t be ignored any longer. Other women will be raped and sexually assaulted as well as young gay men will be preyed upon. Even new comer men will be harassed and many members will be scammed on by members with lots of sobriety. We are so frustrated. But here’s what we have done.
We have held two (2), “Make AA Safer Workshops”. Another District had a workshop in Monrovia, CA. on August 7, 2010. What was revealed was there was a man coming to the meeting and pulling out a gun and putting it in his lap. Using intimidation. No one escorted him out. Only after many times a newer member went to the police station.) They should have known what to do. Step outside, call the police and let them handle it. . People were too afraid to say anything.

When the traditions were first written AA members were carefully screened and only those wanting to get sober came. Everyone knew each other. It was a small fellowship. Around 20 years ago A Judge in Los Angeles began sending DUI’s and criminals to AA meetings who did not want to come to AA. Yet the traditions were never altered to accommodate for these strange new additions to our meetings sitting amongst us. Our traditions have been twisted. And the traditions were never intended to handle criminals. There is no bouncer. No Sergeant at Arms.

We hope all our districts will host workshops like this all over our region. It needs to be addressed and new folks need to be warned that AA is not safe. We feel the general population needs to be warned that things are not so safe in our meetings, nor have they been for years as we have written accounts to highlight this.
We all know what Tradition One is.
Our Common welfare should come first. Personal recovery depends upon AA Unity. “
The principal of this tradition is to Carry the message, not harass and 13step the newcomer!
SO here is a statement that we all seem to like.
We of Alcoholics Anonymous feel that everyone should feel safe. If you don’t’ feel safe please tell the secretary or someone you trust.
"It is up to all of us as individuals in the rooms and in our groups to protect all members, particularly the minor and the new person, whether young or old, from any unsafe, or unspiritual behaviors.” No one should be sexually harassed or financially pressured in any way.
General Service in Every capacity has this same responsibility. Yet it passes it off to the groups at large. Which in no shape, way or form runs AA. That is a complete falsehood.
If Criminal behavior is going on and AAWS is not warning people or taking corrective measures to protect where we can, and our groups see this and also do nothing, then our public relations policy is not promoting attraction! Rather it is breaking the law and turning a blind eye.
We are all mandated reporters.
It’s our understanding that this is the law. Hence, this must be addressed in our preamble, in our literature, on our public website, and at General Service.
This criminal behavior grossly affects our public image. If the public at large knew that;
women have been raped by men in AA, that gay men have been told to take off their clothes to read their 5th step, that women in the Spanish community are taken to the mountains and coerced to have sex with old timer men as part of reading their 5th step to them, we believe things would be very damaging to our society and reputation as a whole.
Great Britain, Australia AA, and CODA in America have published literature and provided it to their fellowships.

  • Awareness must be raised.
  • We want literature written.
  • We want literature read.
  • We want warnings on our website.
  • We want safety posters in the entry way to all AA meetings Halls and clubs.

If churches knew what was going on we could be thrown out of all churches due to liability insurance policies.

So these are the facts told to us since October 2009.
1.At Westside district meeting on Saturday January 23, 2010: A women approached me and told me that a women in her meeting had just been raped by an AA member, in the Pacific Palisades, CA.

2.Tuesday January 26th, 2010. I was contacted by another old-timer and was told another woman was date raped and that she was unsupported by her large group of AA’s.

3.Young woman age 18 was 13 stepped (sexually harassed)by some guy who 13stepped hundreds of women. Most of them did not stay sober. (1975) She was harassed sexually by two middle age men. They wanted her to have sex with them and her sister all together. When she refused a second time they asked her to move out.
4. A Woman age forty, sober two years, at age 5 was molested by a sober man who dated her sober mother. She spoke of her experience at our May16, 2010 all day Area Assembly.
5. A woman who got sober in 1969 told me she was vulnerable when she was new and her daughter was molested by a sober man.
8. April 3, 2010; one 29 year old female was raped by a 49 year old male who is 23 years sober. He took her to a rural area in the mountains and raped her.
(He is now in jail) after 8 months of sitting in meetings intimidating new women with just days of sobriety.
9. Another young woman was taken to abandoned house in Azusa, CA. and raped.
10. A Man with 19 years sober age mid Fifties is taking brand new sober young women to Motel 6, getting them drunk and date rapping them.
11. Newcomers (male & female) have been sexually harassed for dates, sex and money for years…it’s still going on.
12. Oldtimer men have abused their power asking new comers and sponsee’s for money. Happening for years at a big men’s stag in Hollywood by a guy with 30 years of sobriety. When they ask him for their money back he tells them to go write about it!
13. Old timer men have told young new women that needed to have sex with them to get a spiritual awakening. This story was in “Newsweek Magazine” 2007
14.Gay new comers are running to straight meetings to get away from the old timers in West Hollywood.
15. Women are predators too. Male reported he will not attend certain meetings anymore because a woman is preying and hitting on him.
16. AT the PRAASA Predator workshop Mar 2010, I was told that the Spanish Community that there are “24 hours groups” in the United States. In these “24 Hour groups” they are tying people up and forcing them to stay against their will for days on end.
17. At PRAASA another young Spanish girl told of a young man who killed himself recently in regards to a sexual predator. She was crying as she shared this story.

Aren’t we liable if we know that there are meetings that are not safe and still we do nothing? The effective change we want is responsibility on your part along with our grass roots movement. Things have gotten completely out of hand in Los Angeles, CA. And from what I heard at PRAASA it is going on all over the region.

Many of us have stopped going to co ed meetings because the Sexual Predator vibe is so bad
What can be done?
Ask groups all over the country to hold workshops and round table discussion and every regional assembly. (Like NA did 5 years ago) AA’s establish a subcommittee to address this issue and hold workshops with Your Monies with the Professional Community. (NA did this 5 years ago)

Ask groups to read a simple statement in their format.

Issue a release to Treatments Centers
We are not safe.

Issue a release to professionals. We are not safe.

More new facts:
18. Friday Night January 29, 2010. 414 Lincoln in Venice
Three women approached me. Two were raped by sober members.
19. Friday Night Feb 5th, 2010
A male age 52 clean/sober 12 years tells me he is very disturbed with the element of guys he was seeing in the meetings. Who are they? They don’t even look like alcoholics.

The girl who was raped approached me again. She has never gone to the police.

20. Went to Radford Club in Sherman Oaks..
A priest approached me. Late 60’s, sober 22 years. He said “Thank you so much for doing this work. It really needs to be done.” He said “25% percent of all the women he send to AA get harassed and never come back after 1 meeting.”

21. Another man age 62 with 28 years said “it’s been going on all the years he’s been coming to Radford.”
I said but “Rape” he said …worse” He said “I would not believe the things that have happened. All these years!”
A female age 50, sober 18 years said that at a meeting place, Moorpark and Whitsett. there is a man there going up to new pretty girls asking them if they would suck his cock.
Both men and women are Predators.

22. The Marina Center. Male age 32 sober five years said that he was 13 stepped by a women when he was 3 months sober. She had 13 years. He was furious!
23. March 2010, I went to ACYPAA in San Diego.
From the panel on “Keeping Minors Safer in AA” I heard a Judge said he was afraid to send some young women to AA because he knows what might happen.

24. Another panelist said that A sober member who works as a parole officer who works with Sex offenders said” that sex offenders who are being released laugh at us because we are happy hunting grounds for sexual predators. In conclusion, some of them are coming to our meetings. They are not even Alcoholics.

25. February 17, 2010 Young 30 something pretty women came to our meeting on purpose. She heard what we are doing. She was in a treatment center and she was sexually harassed by the Director, a sober member of AA. She was terrified. He actually molested her while giving her a ride in his car.
She was coerced to have sex with him. She left the country she was so afraid.
26. March9, 2010 Marina Center. Culver City, CA.
Another member said that he was so mad that he fantasized about taking a gun and shooting the Sexual Predators at the meetings.
27. Friday Night March 12, 2010.
Rodeo Meeting Young very angry guy said he was a newcomer. And sees the old guys hitting on the new women. Male sober 10 years said older members said to him when he was new “get them while they are new and easy. After they sober up they won’t sleep with you anymore!
He said “it really needs to be addressed.” He also said, “yea there’s four or five guys here doing that.
28. I was told by a male 17 years that he was hit on by a professional prostitute in this meeting.

29. March 29, 2010
A man told me a woman was raped five years ago. After her first meeting she was followed home and raped. She did go to the police.
30. April 1, 2010 a 24 year old, 3 month sober female was harassed by 40 year old male sober 14 years.
She told us a man at The Marina Center was calling and texting and harassing her
Asking her where she was.

She is afraid. He tells her that he needs to know where she is or he might get drunk.

AT PRAASA IN LA…“Predators in AA” was given a late night round table discussion. One Hundred and thirty members attended.
Nine states and 15 regions were represented. They took minutes.
April 7, 2010, Culver City, CA
First MAAS (Make AA Safer) Workshop addressing Sexual and Financial Predators in AA. The minutes are attached in this packet.

The Latest News given to me as a result of handing out our green pamphlet.

31. Gay Male sober 15 years tells us that his first sponsor told him to take his clothes off to read his 5th step.

  1. 24 year old female sober 110 days He is being harassed for money at the Marina Center and she and he were hit on by a couple sober 28 years in their mid 50’s to have sex with them and swing.
  2. Rosie, Harassed at Marina Center touched, sexually harassed. Unsupported by the women. They said stupid stuff to her. She drank and will not return there.
  3. Elli, sexually harassed my member for 5 years, grabbed for 2 more years, then she punched him in the face. They are using our literature.

What would be great?
  • We would love to speak with you on the phone.
  • A letter sent to all GSR’s , Secretary’s and Central Office’s asking them to go to their groups and discuss this topic and start reading a safety statement and making announcements. And knowing we are dealing with Crime we also hope that General Service agrees that we need to address this issue as fast as possible.

Every state could have
  • A Make AA Safer representative that is trained to go to meetings where there is serious trouble.
  • There is a hotline number
  • E mail address
  • Write literature
  • Have a workshop
To support the member to call the police when a crime has been committed

We also feel that the judges, the rehabs and sober living homes need to understand what is really going on in our fellowship right now. (This is a legal liability if our government sends innocent women to AA and they are raped and sexually harassed and battered)

Although we have no control over individuals…Crime is Crime…Inside AA or outside on the street. AA will have a zero tolerance for crime and sexual harassment in our meetings.

In keeping with more then one of our traditions we think AAWS needs be in unity with our fellowship.
As I mentioned earlier, the small percentage of General Service Rep’s representing our vast amounts of groups makes it is easy to see that we are not really connected to NY or even to each other except by word of mouth, and in LA meetings are very spread out. This is where the traditions are NOT working in our urban areas.
Revealed at the MAAS workshop in Covina. A Male age 70, sober 34 years, said “that in the old days they took the bad ones out back and beat THEM UP”. Tear rolls down his face as this oldtimer said he did not know how to handle these predators anymore.

AA is not above the law. Why do AA’ers think they are special and above the law?
Oct 21, 2010
Kristine and Saundra Cass Murdered by AA member she was dating in Honolulu, HI. Aug 20, 2010.”

Man followed woman home from meeting and murders her.
Lance Glock rape in West Covina, CA.

I have personal letters written by the two woman who were raped by the men they met in AA. Both men having teen years sober and 20 years older then most of the woman.

And lastly, A woman wrote me a 6 page letter how her son was 13 and was sexually molested by a sober man (his AA sponsor and was later killed) 2005 it made news and it was a 7 state pedophile ring targeting AA meetings and rehab. * “America’s Most Wanted.”

Nov 6th, 2010. Meeting in West Hollywood. Woman tells me a woman was murdered outside a clubhouse in Glendale in 2007 by a man who everyone knew was mentally unstable. No one told him he had to leave. He stabbed her to death right outside the meeting hall. Says she is really disturbed by the downward turn of AA meetings.

Finally, newest tragedy…Herbert Tracy White Murdered in Downtown Los Angeles by a couple who he met in an AA meeting. They were trying to rob him, things went bad. They stabbed him to death and dismembered him.
It’s true there are good AA people, and they do exist, are being targeted. We feel both newperson and Oldtimer need to be warned. Pretending things are ok is a… bad idea!

Despite the resistance from our District and Area, 45 groups are already using our “Make AA Safer Pamphlet.” It has been translated into Spanish and is being duplicated and posted on the walls of meeting halls in Palm Springs Ca.
About ten meetings have written a safety statement and is read at the beginning of the meeting. My home group provides this Non-approved GSO literature with great pride. Knowing our literature helps raise awareness.
My home group may host one more MAAS (Make AA Safer Workshop in late May 2011. A large Workshop was help in Carlsbad in February 2011.

In Closing I want to say that the idea of sending criminals and DUI’s to meetings was discussed in our fellowship through a group conscious is preposterous. When this began to happen there is no way that 3000 groups in Los Angeles, had a business meeting, discussed the pros & cons in regards to the breaking of the Third tradition. “The only requirement for AA membership is a desire to stop drinking.”
Sending folks to AA when they don’t want to be there greatly infected the vibe, culture and environment that had been an esoteric place where one on one passing of sobriety was now replaced with judgmental, angry participants who were court ordered to attend AA instead of being sent to jail.

I personally sat in meetings in Honolulu when this first happened. It overwhelmed our little meeting at St Augustine’s Church in Downtown Honolulu. We were outraged. But none of us knew what to do.
In Addition to the fact the entire fellowship did not and is not capable of making this kind of decision. When the Traditions were first written, AA was a secret and small society. AA’ers would carefully screen each individual to see if they were really ready. They were in debate as to weather they would allow prostitutes, criminals or nonprofessional types. Once AA got Prison Wardens and the like on their National Board, they began in drove to sent these types to our meetings, but they DID NOT put into place safety measures or rewrite the traditions to attend to the new changes made to letting forced people to attend our intimate meeting setting.

AA touts it self on being non-professional. So why would a judge send hard criminals with a violent past to a group of for treatment. Most of them still don’t handle their anger well. AA’s GSB, its sub committee, has it’s head in the sand. Perhaps many of them don’t remember those days, before court ordered folks. I do. I was sober before it happened. I watched it change AA for the worse.

Unless serious Safety measures are taken and the innocent public are warned I fear that AA will simple die from the inside out. With folks like me and my friends just leaving to create some other kind of support groups, find and make a safer space to support each other with sobriety issues. There are hundreds of thousands of us. You can find us on Stinki-thinkin.com
& stop13stepin aa.wordpress.com
Sincerely,

[name omitted to preserve anonymity – our edit]
sober 35 years
Note* WE already know that it’s a problem that is going on all over the Pacific Region (consists of 9 states and 15 regions) that was discussed in detail at The Pacific Regional Forum last March in Los Angeles at The Round Table discussion for “Sexual and Financial Predators in AA”
And because of the Internet we can follow the stories all over the country and in Europe. Things have really escalated this past 12 months with violent behavior.”


Comment: None required

The Fellas (Friends of Alcoholics Anonymous)