AA MINORITY REPORT 2017 (revised)

Click here

Monday 14 July 2014

AA – a religion in the making!


Observations of an AA member:

One characteristic of cults is that they take phrases, sayings, teachings of standard, moderate religions (or from other sources) and modify them slightly to produce a different effect. An effect that serves the cult's goals of control and isolation of its members. An example of this practice which I have noticed in New York City is the use of the phrase "primary purpose". The official Tradition states that it is the GROUP that has a primary purpose to carry its message to the alcoholic who still suffers.  I have heard several people say that they are encouraged by the fact that they personally, as individuals, learned in AA that they have that same primary purpose. I have problems with that. First, that it is not how the Tradition reads. But more importantly is that it, first, ties the individual members primarily to the AA group to the exclusion of meaningful relations and activities outside the group. (Not logically, one could have secondary purposes I guess, but that does not appear to be how it works in practice.) And secondly, it violates the principle that I can practice my religion or spirituality (which could be philosophical) without interference from AA. As it says in one of the Appendices, to paraphrase, AA makes better Catholics of Catholics, etc.

Well, let me tell you, carrying the message of AA is not what one is taught is one's "primary purpose" in the Catholic faith. And I suspect not in most versions of orthodox Protestantism or Judaism. I would extend that right to other spiritual paths any AA may want to pursue along side AA, namely the right of the spiritual tradition to ask its members to adopt a primary purpose other than the one proposed by these fundamentalist members of AA. AA sets itself up as a competing religion when it goes beyond the bounds set for it in the Traditions and starts preaching primary purposes for its members' lives.”

Cheers

The Fellas (Friends of Alcoholics Anonymous)

Our thanks to the above for their contribution

No comments:

Post a Comment